Fresh roasted coffee, warm buttery biscuits
In a red and white converted garage on the shoulder of Red Arrow Highway, Jessica Nance knows that when you walk through her door, you might still be waking up. You’re probably hungry, too. That’s why, at her small-batch coffee roastery Red Arrow Roasters, she takes every cup of coffee and warm, honey-buttered biscuit very seriously.
Coffee and biscuits. They’re the only items on the menu. (Other than tea.) And on a typical Saturday, you’ll see a steady stream of people making it their No. 1 priority to get their hands on both. Because, thanks to Jess’s precision and skill, they’re getting one of the most delicious, carefully considered coffee-and-a-biscuit combos out there.
“If you’re gonna make something, make it the best,” she says with the baked-in determination of a former Division I athlete, which she is. (She swam for Ball State.) Jess roasts her beans eight pounds at a time, observing every minute of the roast. She obsesses over equipment and each measurement. And it’s worth it.
Her coffees are mellow, well-balanced, and rich, with a pleasant complexity that can make even the most stubborn half-and-half people go black. You’ll find Red Arrow roasts in cafés and bakeries across Harbor Country, including neighbors Whistle Stop and Luisa’s Swedish Bakery. You can take them home, too, with as many as seven whole-bean blends to choose from.
A toasty cup of coffee in the morning, brewed from freshly roasted beans: So simple, but also just the best. Especially with a steamy biscuit.
words Lena Singer
images Jessica Steele
November 2026